[Ludmila]

I would like to share with you my problem that I am currently solving. I have two sources of teaching – I respect both teachers and consider them very capable. However, they have different opinions on some points within the framework of tonification and harmonization of the Heavenly Stems. Specifically, for example, when harmonizing the yang Stem through the control cycle, one teacher uses the dispersion technique and the other the tonification technique So if  I want to harmonize, for example, the Stem Keng and one teacher recommends dispersing Ki 2 and the other tonifying Ki 2. Since Stem treatment is very important and only one needle is used, it must be essential to choose the right technique. Can you advise me on this? Thank you

[Joan]

Thank you for this important question. First of all, I would like to clarify that working with Stems and Branches is never based on a fixed protocol. What one intends to treat must be perceptible and observable through the chosen diagnostic method. In my case, this always involves pulse and body diagnosis.

Returning to your question: when the Great Movement Metal with the Heavenly Stem Geng becomes overactive (and for now I will assume that this is the Stem of the birth chart), we must first determine through the pulse whether this is caused by an imbalance of the like and/or unlike qi. However, there are also other possible causes beyond just like and unlike qi. It would go too far to discuss all of them here.

In the situation described above, when the Great Movement Fire becomes overactive, this is normally because the Great Movement Wood is being excessively suppressed by the Great Movement Metal. The Great Movement Fire then attempts to take “revenge” in an effort to restore a healthy kind of balance. Sedating Ki-2 may seem like a good option in such a case (rather than tonifying), but this approach is purely symptomatic and would only be appropriate in life-threatening situations. The practitioner must investigate why the Qi of both the Great Movement Fire and Metal has become so excessive. This may, for example, be influenced by a person’s diet, daily work, lifestyle, or overall life circumstances. Therefore, it makes much more sense to explore these factors first.
In addition, it is even more essential to examine the deeper reasons why the Great Movement Wood has become deficient. This can very easily occur due to its relationship with the Stem Ting and/or Shen. In this area, the solution is often found sooner than in the Great Movement of Fire.
In Constitutional Acupuncture, it is not customary to sedate excessively, and certainly not to sedate Stem points, because doing so would sedate the essential Qi.

Let me express this clearly and with full respect: Stems and Branches Acupuncture can appear mathematical in nature, and this can sometimes lead to very technical or formula-based solutions. However, the essence is always to see the human being behind the diagnosis, and to offer that person the conditions in which the self-healing capacity can function.
Constitutional Acupuncture opens the door to healing, but the path each person takes through that door is their own. We may all wish for quick results, but true healing cannot be forced.

Best wishes, Joan

[Author]

Posts